Let me tell you about a tarot card reader. She’s made up, but I bet you know her. She sells 60-minute readings for $175. A client books, pays, and logs onto Zoom. She gives an in-depth and honest reading. Some of it isn’t what the client wants to hear (the cards don’t do customer service, but that’s kind of the point). Three weeks later, a chargeback shows up. Reason: “Service not as described.”
Now she has to prove to a bank that she delivered something you can’t hold or ship. What’s her evidence, you ask? A booking confirmation and a really good vibe. But as it turns out, banks don’t accept vibes.
Full disclosure: I’m not only a lawyer here. I’m a client too, so I get what you do and why it matters to the people who book you. I also know it’s really, really hard to protect. So, let’s fix that.
You’re Selling the Session, not the Future
I tell every coach that I work with the same thing: your client is buying the session, not the outcome. Your business works exactly the same way. You deliver insight, guidance, and energy. What happens next is up to the client. Did they take your advice? Ignore it? Text their ex anyway? (They texted their ex. They always text their ex.)
The difference is that most people get coaching, but most banks don’t get your work. Your contract is what explains it for you.
“Wait, fortune telling is a crime in New York?”
Believe it or not, technically yes. New York Penal Law § 165.35 makes it a crime to take money for telling fortunes or to claim you can use occult powers to give advice on personal matters. It even covers claiming you can lift curses or influence evil spirits (nope, I didn’t make that up). It’s a class B misdemeanor and can result in up to three months in prison and a $500 fine. Before you panic, it’s not always enforced. Gothamist found just 11 complaints and four arrests over 15 years. Bills to repeal it were introduced earlier this year, but they haven’t passed yet.
The one big exception is for services offered solely for entertainment or amusement. That’s where the disclaimer on every psychic website comes from, but that tiny gray line doesn’t cover cancellations, refunds, or chargebacks. A disclaimer is just a sentence. With a contract, you have an actual plan.
For those of you who are outside of New York, some states and towns have their own rules, including licensing. For the love of all things mystic, please check both.
Tell Them Exactly What They’re Buying
You’re not handing your client a physical product, but name every single tangible thing you can. We’re talking session length, format, recordings, and follow-up questions. “A reading” is the vibe. “A 60-minute live video reading, plus a recording emailed within 48 hours” is a service. The bank can’t exactly judge a tarot reading, so give it something it can look at.
Don’t Promise the Future…Ironic, I Know
Your contract should clearly say that you don’t guarantee a specific outcome. That includes new jobs, a reunion with an old flame, winning lottery tickets, the lot.
It should also say that you’re not their doctor, therapist, lawyer, or financial advisor. That might seem obvious. Put it in writing anyway. Make sure you include that the client is responsible for their own decisions. If they decide to move to Sedona after a reading, that’s on them…and more power to them.
Mercury Retrograde Isn’t a Cancellation Policy
When a client cancels the morning of their reading, you can’t resell that hour. Cover cancellation notice, no-shows, and the client who shows up 25 minutes late to a 30-minute reading. And yes, you only give them a five-minute reading. Do the crime, get shorter time…or something like that. Don’t forget your refund policy, too. There’s a difference between “I didn’t like my reading” and “I didn’t get what I paid for.” Make sure that’s crystal clear in your contract.
Your Instagram Bio Is Writing Checks Your Contract Can’t Cash
The contract says, “No guaranteed results” while your bio says, “Guaranteed to bring you your soulmate in 30 days.” Guess which one the client screenshots?
Remember, your contract isn’t the only place where you’re making promises. Your sales page, your social media captions, your DMs, and yes, even the testimonial from Stacey saying you “saved her marriage” are all telling your clients what to expect. If a client files a chargeback, guess what they’re attaching as evidence? Not your thoughtful refund policy, I’ll tell you that.
A disclaimer at the bottom of a web page is great, but it doesn’t undo a promise you made at the top. Before you post, do a quick gut check. If you wouldn’t put your caption in a contract, try again. Your marketing and your contract should tell the same story…preferrably with an ending that doesn’t involve a court room.
The Cards Say It’s Time for a Contract Check
Your work is real and important, even if it’s hard to measure. Just remember, if you can’t hold it in your hand, your contract has to prove you delivered it. If you’re reading all of this and thinking, “Hmmm, does my contract say all of this?” Fabulous question! Let’s find out together. You can leave the crystal ball at home this time.
This post is for educational purposes and isn’t legal advice. Every business is different, and laws vary by state and city, so talk to an attorney about your specific business.